Includes the resolution, context, pro and con, sample motions, and web links and print resources. Choose from 4 different sets of webster hayne debate, 1830 flashcards on quizlet. Americas great debate saved union from war the civil war remains the bloodiest conflict in u. Calhouns theory of nullificationthe right of a state to overturn federal laws it considered unconstitutionalwhich webster attacked.
Not only did i rediscover the history of the debate itself, but also how the debate illustrates the different ways in which americans have understood what it means to be a nation. The webster hayne debate, extending from january to may 1830, was the most important event to occur in this legislative session. Hayne, who had vastly different ideas about nationhood. In the first years of andrew jacksons presidency, senators robert y. By this time, visitors packed the senate hoping to see hayne take it to webster. Nov 06, 2007 webster s relatively brief response on january 20 confronted haynes states rights theme and succeeded in shifting the debate from the narrow issues of the tariff and public land policy to the more cosmic concerns of slavery and the very nature of the union. Find an answer to your question the debate between webster and hayne took place in which branch of government. Websterhayne debate simple english wikipedia, the free. Get an answer for why was the hayne webster debate important. That question led me to write the webster hayne debate. They adorned statues of webster and the facades of public buildings. The great debate between hayne and webster, the speech of. Lets practice debating in english iii preface this book will help the reader to understand the basics in debating and work on notetaking exercises and critical questions on a debate about legalizing euthanasia. Apr 12, 2018 webster hayne debate 1830 sister projects.
The websterhayne debate, extending from january to may 1830, was the most important event to occur in this legislative session. The most eloquent speech ever delivered in congress may have been webster s 1830 second reply to hayne, a south carolina senator who had enunciated the calhoun case for states rights. Yet in modern times the debate has been relegated to a few lines in college textbooks. The main competing arguments in the webster hayne debate which took place between senator daniel webster of massachusetts and senator robert y. The debate can be seen as a precursor to the debate that became important at the. The websterhayne debate was a famous debate in the united states between senator daniel. Info on the websterhayne debate the scoop on historyapush. For over 100 years after webster first spoke those words in 1830, one could find them in history books and oratory manuals.
At the level of partisan politics, hayne supported the inexpensive sale of public lands. Hayne of south carolina and thomas hart benton of missouri shaped a potentially powerful southern and western alliance. At the request of the president, congress passed the force bill which approved the use of the army if needed. In 1833, henry clay made a compromise that would make the tariff lower over several years. The debate cemented the image of daniel webster, as a legendary. The haynewebster debate and how jackson responds by jessica. Hayne was one of the younger members of the senate. The speeches between webster and hayne themselves were not planned. The webster hayne debate played a role in shaping american attitudes about the federal government. None of the other states chose to support south carolina. Hayne of south carolina that took place on january 1927, 1830 on the topic of protectionist tariffs. The importance of the debate was that it brought into focus two conflicting views on the central issue of the nature of the union and a whole cluster of issues about american government webster defending a nationalist view against haynes states rights view.
Full text of the great debate between hayne and webster. The debatabase book a musthave guide for successful debate. What was haynes point of view in the haynes webster debate. The senate debates between whig senator daniel webster of massachusetts and democrat senator robert y. The heated speeches between webster and hayne themselves were unplanned, and stemmed from debate over a resolution by connecticut senator samuel a. Hayne s nephew, paul hamilton hayne, was a poet and south carolinas poet laureate who moved to georgia after the civil war. Debate on this matter continued over a number of weeks and changed from a discussion of land policy into a debate about the nature of the union. The great debate between hayne and webster hathitrust. Use this quiz and worksheet to test your knowledge of this debate. The debate between webster and hayne took place in which.
A fourspeech debate between daniel webster of massachusetts and robert hayne of south carolina, in january 1830. The websterhayne debate on the nature of the union. Webster hayne debate, 1830 flashcards and study sets quizlet. Heirs of the founders looks at efforts to stave off. But webster uses tariff as if it were synonymous with the american system, and uses it over and over. Why would a unionist represent unionism by its least popular aspect.
Websterhayne debate wikisource, the free online library. Webster hayne debate 1830, an unplanned series of speeches in the senate, during which robert hayne of south carolina interpreted the constitution as little more than a treaty between sovereign states, and daniel webster expressed the concept of the united states as one nation. Therefore, this guide is to help you understand the most important features students need to understand to get started in debate. The treaties enacted under this acts provisions paved the way for the reluctantand often forcibleemigration of tens of thousands of american indians to the west. Hayne of south carolinawere over protective tariffs in the united states, with one side arguing that states had a right to nullify laws they deemed unconstitutional, and the other argued that the union needed to be protected at all costs. The speech of daniel webster in reply to robert young hayne 1898 paperback september 10, 2010. This pattern is maintained for the second and third speakers of each team. Presents background, arguments, and resources on approximately 150 debate topics in diverse areas.
Why has the webster hayne debate been largely forgotten. The websterhayne debate johns hopkins university press. Perhaps because it draws hayne into explicit discussion of the tariff, and a defense of nullification, which webster wants an opportunity to attack. This is a book to make debating as simple as possible. There is not enough time to adequately prepare students for everything they need to know in debate.
A read is counted each time someone views a publication summary such as the title, abstract, and list of authors, clicks on a figure, or views or downloads the fulltext. Nov 07, 2007 what is the significance of websterhayne debate. Get an answer for what was haynes point of view in the haynes webster debate and find homework help for other history questions at enotes. The websterhayne debate on the nature of the union essentially is the nationalist interpretation visavis the compact interpretation of the union. What were the competing arguments in the websterhayne debate. Give it your best shot, but be prepared to let you mind be changed. Part i of the book is an introductory textbook of debating, especially academic or educational debate. The websterhayne debate was a famous debate in the united states between senator daniel webster of massachusetts and senator robert y.
Search the worlds most comprehensive index of fulltext books. The great debate between hayne and webster, the speech of daniel webster in reply to robert young hayne. Most of all, this book should help you to make debating fun. History has all but forgotten websters debate partner, south carolina senator robert y. Websters original participation in the debate unpremeditated. The websterhayne debate on the nature of the union quotes showing 11 of 1 liberty and union, now and for ever, one and inseparable. Daniel webster s reply to robert hayne during an 1830 senate debate. Other characters entered the argument, most notably daniel webster of massachusetts and robert young hayne of south carolina. Learn webster hayne debate, 1830 with free interactive flashcards. Resumed trade with britain and france until one of them ended its restrictions against american trade, at which point the us would place n embargo on the other. The great debate between hayne and webster, the speech of daniel webster in reply to robert young hayne on.
You learned here national speech debate association i. The websterhayne debate on the nature of the constitution. The dominant historical opinion of the famous debate between daniel webster of massachusetts and robert young hayne of south carolina which took place in the united states senate in 1830 has long been that webster defeated hayne both as an orator and a statesman. The websterhayne debate was a series of unplanned speeches in the senate between january 19th and 27th of 1830 between senator daniel. Push definition is to press against with force in order to drive or impel.
The first affirmative speaker begins the debate, and is then followed by the first negative speaker. The webster hayne debate was a series of unplanned speeches in the senate between january 19th and 27th of 1830 between senator daniel. What was the main issue of the websterhayne debate. The websterhayne debates teaching american history.
Hopefully, this book will help you to develop the right skills and strategies to be a successful debater. The opening of the twentyfirst congress on december 7, 1829, marked the first meeting of the national legislature following jacksons inauguration in march of that year. Historian forest mcdonald avows, the constitution would be a compact not among sovereign states, as was the 1781 articles of confederation, nor a lockean compact between ruler and ruled. The hayne webster debate was an unplanned series of speeches in the senate, during which robert hayne of south carolina interpreted the constitution as little more than a treaty between sovereign states, and daniel webster expressed the concept of the united states as one nation. Daniel webster, the websterhayne debate on the nature of the union. The websterhayne debate on the nature of the union quotes. Debate training guide training debaters is a continual process.
What followed, the webster hayne debate, was one of the most famous. The readings in this book can also be supplemented by visiting the. The main issue of the webster hayne debate was the nature of the country that had been created by the constitution. The hayne webster debate of 1830 pitted daniel webster, a senator from massachusetts who represented the tradition of the federalist party which had.